The nature of renovations is such that you can pretty much guarantee something will go wrong.
Renovators will never know exactly what they’re going to find behind your walls until they open them up. If they’re experienced, they’ll have a good idea of typical things they might find, like knob and tube wiring in an old Glebe home, but they can still hit obstacles with the unexpected.
A good example is celebrity contractor Bryan Baeumler. He’s had several shows on HGTV and his latest, called Island of Bryan, shows how a project can go spectacularly off the rails. In his case, he knew what he was getting into and chose to dive in anyway, but still…
A year behind schedule
For close to two years, Bryan and his wife, Sarah, worked to restore an abandoned boutique hotel resort in the Bahamas, an adventure that is being chronicled on the show. (Editor’s note: season 2 began airing in February on HGTV.)
Their initial plan was to take six months renovating enough of the property so that they could open last fall. A year later they still hadn’t opened, although they did begin accepting reservations toward the end of last year.
Their journey is an example of how problem after problem delayed progress, chewed up their budget and forced a rethink of many of their plans.
If someone as well known and experienced as Bryan Baeumler can have a project go off the rails, does that mean you’re doomed to the same fate?
Not at all. It just means you have to be prepared.
“There are always surprises, but part of doing a good project is knowing they will happen and how you react when they happen.”
Owner, ARTium Design Build & Just Basements
7 key steps
Keeping your reno from going off the rails comes down to 7 key things, and the responsibility is on both you as the homeowner and whoever you hire to do your project. Those 7 keys are:
- Plan, plan, plan
- Hire pros
- Budget well
- Get it in writing
- Be flexible
- Stick to your plan
So, what does it mean to have a reno go off the rails?
It can mean several things, but typically involves going over budget and/or blowing your timeline. And those two issues usually crop up thanks to hidden obstacles and something referred to as scope creep.
Scope creep is when the defined parameters of the job increase or balloon because after the project has begun, you think of other things you want to add on, such as deciding to replace all the flooring on your main floor when you were initially planning to just renovate your kitchen.
Let’s take a closer look at those 7 keys.
No. 1: Plan, plan, plan… and plan some more
Bryan Baeumler would be the first to tell you that the best way to keep your project on track is to plan, plan, plan. Part of the reason his resort project went sideways is because they jumped in so quickly.
He admits that it probably would have been better to take two years to plan it out first (instead of just a couple of months), but that kind of timeline was not part of their business plan for the project.
“We knew what we were getting ourselves into,” he says. “It was chaos trying to plan and manage a project as you’re into it.”
Ottawa’s top renovators emphasize the importance of planning. It’s the cornerstone of every successful project, from a simple DIY to a major overhaul of your home.
“Prepare, prepare, prepare — I can’t stress that enough. An hour spent up front saves three or more down the road,” says Brent Young, president of Carleton Kitchen & Bath.
“How many times do we hear that projects are months behind schedule and thousands of dollars over budget — and it’s all preventable. A successful project is all about planning.”
What does planning mean?
First, it means defining your goals, says Steve Barkhouse, president of Amsted Design-Build, which was just named the provincial renovator of the year for a record third time by the Ontario Home Builders’ Association. “Really know what it is that you want to achieve.”
- What works in your space right now and what doesn’t?
- What are must haves and what are nice to have if your budget allows?
- What’s the future of your home? Is your family growing? Are kids moving away? Will you be downsizing? Is it your forever home or will you move in a few years?
Be sure to write all of these things down, adds Lecuyer. Once you’ve done that, you can take a look at the scope of your project to help you determine whether you have the budget for it and what kind of renovator you’ll need. (More on budgets and hiring in a bit.)
And once you have your team in place you can start on the design. For all but the most basic remodel, it’s wise to have it professionally designed, whether that’s through an independent designer or architect you’ve chosen or through your renovation firm’s in-house design staff.
“The biggest mistake people make is seeing design as a luxury service and they really need to realize it is an essential service,” says Moneca Kaiser of Moneca Kaiser Design Build. “It’s the only way to control cost and ensure value.”
It also makes it easier for you and your team to choose all your features and finishes before construction begins, which is a crucial step in keeping things from going off the rails. Specialized materials, in particular, can slow things down if they get back ordered.
And having all of these decisions made ahead of time means there is one less thing to have to remember once construction has begun.
Don’t jump in too soon
When it comes to construction, don’t be in a rush to jump into this stage, says Young. Rushing into things before they are properly planned out is a recipe for going off the rails.
Often a renovation is spurred by things happening in our lives, like a baby on the way or wanting a project done before Christmas so you can host the family for dinner, adds Lecuyer, but these are not good reasons to start prematurely. You’ll just cause more grief in the end.
“You’re better to delay that start date and start when everything is ready than to start it early and have delays in the project because things aren’t in yet or not prepared,” says Young.
Bumps in the road
It’s also important to plan for bumps in the road, says Lecuyer, because you’re almost guaranteed that something will come up to slow down your project. But if you’re working with a good company, they will draw on their experience to anticipate and see patterns to plan for what they can, he says.
For instance, for the past five years or so, ARTium & Just Basements have not found any cases of iron piping in Ottawa homes that is still viable. That has prompted the firm to recommend to its clients that if they have cast iron piping to budget for replacement because if the company has to break up the slab to connect new plumbing, they will invariably find that the old piping is no longer holding up.
Experienced firms will do as much investigation as they can ahead of time to determine what they’re dealing with in a home. That includes cutting holes in walls to peek inside and bringing through their electricians, plumbers and other trades to identify red flags.
This is an example of a complex project that finished on time, thanks to careful planning before construction.
The project by Lagois Design-Build-Renovate involved demolishing a poorly done old addition and failing deck and replacing them with a much more functional two-storey addition that respected its neighbourhood.
It was a five-month project that did have hiccoughs along the way such as discovering after construction had begun that there was some incorrect plumbing that had to be fixed, but Lagois says that in their exit interview once the job was done, the clients gave the company a 10 out of 10 score on the experience.
In another example, this project below by Carleton Kitchen & Bath is a good illustration of preparation versus execution.
This renovation took 12 weeks to complete, but the planning stage was closer to two years, Young says. That was partly because the homeowners needed almost a year to decide how much of a renovation they wanted to do, but then there was another 10 months of designs and revisions before they were ready to go.
It’s a good example of why it’s so important to thoroughly plan everything out before you start.
“People always underestimate the amount of planning that a renovation takes.”
Vice-president, Gemstone Corp.
Something else to be aware of in your planning is what’s known as the Designated Substances Report. This is something that many in the industry either aren’t aware of or choose to brush off as insignificant, says Barkhouse. But it’s something that can not only derail your project, it can end up costing you a lot of money.
As Barkhouse explains, many people aren’t aware that it’s the property owner’s responsibility to make sure their home is free of certain designated substances, such as asbestos, before work begins on a renovation or a repair.
There are specific designated substances found in many Ottawa homes that can be hazardous to occupants and workers when disturbed during construction. And these need to be identified before any work begins.
You don’t even need to be in an old home to be affected by this. Any Ottawa home built before 1994 needs to have a report done before work begins. If you’re working with a reputable firm, they should bring this to your attention and many will facilitate getting the report done for you, building the cost into their estimate.
If you don’t get the report done, the Ministry of Labour can shut down your project and possibly fine you, and you leave yourself open to a potential lawsuit should a worker come back claiming they were adversely affected by working on your home because designated substances were present.
When it comes to planning your renovation and your initial research, the Canadian Home Builders’ Association (CHBA) and the Greater Ottawa Home Builders’ Association (GOHBA) both offer helpful tips and advice. The CHBA even includes worksheets to help you plan.
You’ll also find lots of helpful advice on All Things Home.
No. 2: Hire pros
Another sure-fire way to have your reno go off the rails is in not hiring the right person for the job. We’ve all heard the horror stories of a reno gone south because of a contractor who skipped out or because the work was so shoddy that it had to be ripped out and done over again.
But if you take the time to carefully vet your renovator, you shouldn’t have a problem.
Baeumler likens the process to choosing a spouse because it really is a relationship you’re creating and since you’re trusting that person with your biggest asset and your haven, you want to be sure you do trust them.
“You want to make sure you’ve hired someone that you can talk to, someone that you trust, someone you have a good relationship with,” he says.
There are different routes to go when choosing someone for your project, depending on your needs and resources. Not everyone can afford an architect or a designer, for instance. Or maybe you want to manage the project yourself, or maybe you just need a small contractor for a small job rather than a big design-build firm.
So, how do you find someone?
Referrals: Many of the good firms, whether a small contractor or a big design-build company, get most of their work through referrals. So, start with friends and family you trust who have had work done and ask if they’d recommend their contractor.
GOHBA/RenoMark: The local housing association is another option. Members have to follow a code of ethics, providing some assurance to homeowners. Within the association is a program called RenoMark, which provides even stricter guidelines for participating companies, who are pre-screened and must meet strict guidelines for things such as insurance, workers’ compensation coverage and credibility.
All Things Home: This site is, fundamentally, a resource site for homeowners. It includes growing directories of professionals that you can turn to when you’re starting your search. Although we don’t specifically endorse the companies listed in the directories, if they have been included then they have at least had a first-level check to make sure they are reputable.
Baeumler Approved: Baeumler started the Baeumler Approved program as a way to help homeowners navigate the home improvement and building industry. The companies included have been vetted, although you still need to do your due diligence. The last time we checked, there were about 40 Ottawa companies listed, although they’re divided into very specific categories such as insulation or masonry and there aren’t any for renovator or design-build, although there is one for general contractor.
BBB: The Better Business Bureau is helpful not only for the big guys but for some of the smaller ones, too, and the BBB is an impartial way to check on a company.
For some of the small firms, it can be more difficult to figure out whether you can trust them, says Lecuyer, particularly since anyone can create a good-looking website these days, not just the ones with big bucks. If they don’t have a portfolio and don’t mention how long they’ve been in business, be wary.
OakWood vice-president of operations Patricia Liptak-Satov points out that you also need to pay attention to how long they’ve been in business under the same name.
“Unfortunately, many contractors get into trouble, bankrupt their company, and then start a new business with a different name,” she says. “Many also simply total up the number of years of everyone in the company to come up with an impressive number — so 10 people with three years’ experience translates into 30 years of experience.”
Once you have a shortlist of possible companies or contractors, you need to research and interview them. The CHBA has a great list of questions to ask on their website, but one you’ll definitely want to ask is for a list of references and whether or not you can visit a current job site to get an idea of how they work.
And don’t neglect to check out the references, including visiting the clients’ homes. “It’s not a guarantee that their next job will be great but it’s better than nothing,” says Lecuyer.
Reno Tour 2019
If you’re researching renovators in the fall, there’s a great opportunity to both see their work and ask them questions. Every fall, usually in October, several of Ottawa’s top renovators, who are all RenoMark members, take part in a house tour showcasing some of their recent renovation projects.
On last fall’s tour, you could visit everything from an ensuite bathroom remake to whole home renovations, additions and even a coach house in Hintonburg. (A few weeks before the next tor, we will have an article detailing what you can expect to see.)
Choose your team based on your project, your personality, your needs, and your budget, says Barkhouse. “Choose carefully — people don’t do that, they rush into choosing someone, but that’s not the way to choose.”
If you want to try hunting online for someone, you can try an online forum like the Facebook group Find a Contractor Ottawa, but keep in mind that those folks have not been vetted and you need to check them out very thoroughly.
No. 3: Have a realistic budget
If you’ve never dipped your toe into renovations, you may have no idea how much a renovation should cost you. There are a lot of variables and you really won’t know until you start getting estimates from renovators, but it’s helpful to have at least a ballpark idea.
So, it’s helpful to come up with a realistic budget and that means doing some research. One place to start is the annual Cost vs. Value Report put out by Remodeling Magazine. Although it has U.S. pricing, you can extrapolate to give you an idea.
Then it’s a matter of being forthcoming with your renovator, says Young. Many homeowners don’t like to reveal just how much they’re willing to spend because they fear their renovator will try to find ways to use up the whole budget, but if you trust your renovator and are honest with them, they can help you to find ways to get the most out of your budget and stretch how far it can go.
Your contingency fund
It’s also important to plan for contingencies. That means setting aside a portion of your budget to deal with those unexpected surprises that come up, like finding wonky wiring behind your walls. Your contingency fund is not for extras like switching to a marble backsplash after already deciding on porcelain tiles.
We often hear celebrity contractors say your contingency fund should be 25 or 30% of your budget, which is a huge amount. Most good local companies recommend a 10% contingency fund, saying that they should be able to effectively anticipate likely issues that will come up so that you don’t need an overly large contingency fund.
Homeowners assume contractors are all essentially the same and based on that, they assume the lowest price will give them the best value and save them money, notes Liptak-Satov.
“But often the lowest price costs them the most. If a contractor’s price is significantly lower, there’s a reason. They haven’t included something in their proposal, which isn’t discovered until the project starts, or they have quoted on much lower quality options.”
If it sounds too good to be true, it likely is.
No. 4: Get everything in writing
One of the best ways to protect yourself as a consumer and help keep things on track is to make sure you and your renovator have a signed contract that details everything, from the scope of work to the materials that will be used to the schedule of work, to when payments are to be made, to what happens if a product needs to be substituted.
“Everything needs to be planned very clearly, everybody needs to understand it and it needs to be documented so that everybody understands it, and then it needs to be signed,” says Barkhouse.
One way to put yourself at risk of your project going off the rails is to be tempted by a lower “cash only” offer, which means you have no protection, or by automatically opting for the lowest offer. Make sure you’re choosing someone reputable and make sure you have a signed contract.
Written agreements and contracts are important even if you’re DIYing, says Young. There will be some professionals you need to hire, like an electrician or a plumber. If you have only verbal agreements it can lead to conflict and miscommunication, while a written record helps everyone involved to “remember” what’s been discussed and decided on.
There are different types of contracts that can be used. The CHBA explains them in detail.
No. 5: Be flexible
“(A reno) requires as much planning as a new home and it requires way more flexibility,” says Josh Zaret, vice-president, Gemstone Corp.
We need to be flexible because no matter how much we plan, something will come up to disrupt that plan.
“100% of the time you will find things you don’t expect,” says Baeumler.
That means you need to be prepared to shift gears, make changes and adjust.
In this project by Amsted, StyleHaus Interiors and Irpinia Kitchens for instance, a structural pole was found within the millwork during the kitchen demolition that required an adjustment to the cabinet layout. The team was able to come up with a way to integrate the pole seamlessly while avoiding extra costs and without compromising storage.
It becomes a balance between planning and having some flexibility as the process unrolls so that you can roll with the punches.
And in this main-floor renovation by OakWood, rodents were discovered in the ceiling. Fixing the issue meant having to take down the ceiling, which turned out to be a blessing in disguise, says Liptak-Satov. Since there were no rooms above the kitchen, dining room or living room, OakWood was able to create a cathedral ceiling to join all three spaces.
Another way you can help to minimize disruption, particularly when it comes to materials, is by writing down a plan B when you’re in the planning stage, says Young. That way if a material you want — like a particular tile — is no longer available or will be delayed too long, rather than going back to square one, you can easily transition to the next option.
No. 6: Communication
Communication is key to a successful project and one that top companies will not shy away from. Your renovator needs to be in regular contact with you to ensure a smooth project, says RND Construction owner Roy Nandram.
At the same time, as a homeowner, be involved and ask questions, says Zaret. “Don’t be afraid to go and see what’s happening. So many people are intimidated by a renovation.” If you’re there every step of the way, you’ll likely come out more satisfied and things won’t pile up as a surprise.
When you’re interviewing potential renovators, find out what their process is for communicating. If it’s something they do not put much stock in, that should be a red flag. “The key is constant communication,” says Nandram.
No. 7: Minimize change orders
Change orders is the term most in the industry use for things that need to be altered during construction. They are not part of the original contract and typically require extra planning, time and money.
Change orders are one of the quickest ways to go over budget and probably occur about half of the time, says Young. Even if it’s something simple, like asking your renovator to paint an extra room, that extra time will interfere with the contractor’s schedule since they’ll already be booked for the next client. It might also disrupt the schedule of trades that your renovator has arranged for your project.
At some point, says Baeumler, you’re going to feel like your renovation has gone off the rails.
“It’s a dirty, messy, invasive, expensive endeavour full of blood sweat and tears. That being said, the best you can do is plan for it — plan, plan, plan, plan, before you do anything.
“If houses and renovations came like Lego in a box, where every piece had its place and you just click them all together… then that would be great. But that is not how we build and renovate.”
Originally posted Sept. 26, 2019.